Why Do Shoulder Dislocations Become Recurrent? Understanding Bankart & Hill-Sachs Lesions
Because the shoulder has the greatest range of motion of any joint in the body, it is also the most prone to dislocation. When the humeral head is forced out of the glenoid socket during a fall or sports injury, the anterior-inferior stabilizing fibrocartilage rim (labrum) tears away from the bone—an injury known as a Bankart Lesion. Frequently, an indentation fracture on the back of the humeral head (Hill-Sachs Lesion) occurs simultaneously.
In young, active patients under age 25, this torn labral bumper rarely heals back to its anatomical footprint on its own, leading to an 80–90% recurrence rate. Over time, every subsequent dislocation erodes the bony socket, until the shoulder begins dislocating during simple daily movements like putting on a coat, reaching overhead, or even turning over in sleep.
Who Needs Surgery for Recurrent Shoulder Dislocation?
Following orthopedic instability tests, high-resolution MRI, and 3D CT bone-stock assessment by Prof. Dr. Nevzat Selim Gokay at our private medical practice in Nisantasi, Sisli, Istanbul, surgical stabilization is indicated for:
- Patients who have experienced two or more shoulder dislocations or recurrent subluxation episodes
- Young, active athletes with a confirmed Bankart labral tear on MRI following a first-time traumatic dislocation
- Individuals who avoid overhead movements or sports due to persistent apprehension that the shoulder will slip out
- Cases showing progressive glenoid bone loss or Hill-Sachs engagement from repeated dislocations
Arthroscopic Bankart Repair, Remplissage, and Latarjet Stabilization
Based on precise pre-operative imaging at our practice, stabilization is tailored to your anatomy. In patients without critical bone loss, Arthroscopic Bankart Repair reattaches the torn labrum and tightens the stretched capsule using bioabsorbable suture anchors through three 0.5 cm portals. When an engaging Hill-Sachs lesion is present, an arthroscopic Remplissage procedure is added; in cases with significant glenoid bone loss, a coracoid bone-block transfer (Latarjet procedure) restores rock-solid stability.
When your shoulder joint dislocates, your ligaments will also tear…
The shoulder joint is the joint with the most mobility in the body. Despite such a wide range of motion, the joint remains in place and continues to function, thanks to the ligaments and tissues called labrum that prevent the shoulder joint from dislocating. If our shoulder joint is subjected to excessive strain in an inverted position, it can become dislocated, often forward. When the shoulder joint is dislocated, a tear develops in the ligaments and labrum. As a result of these ligaments and labrum not healing for any reason, a disease called “Recurrent Shoulder Dislocation” occurs.
By repairing your torn ligaments, re-dislocation of your shoulder joint can be prevented…
In such a case, the shoulder joint will be dislocated during simple daily activities or sports activities. Since every dislocation damages the shoulder bones, it is a condition that must be treated. The treatment is to surgically repair the torn labrum and ligaments where they were torn.
It can be done in two ways;
We restore your joint to health without opening it…
The current treatment method for uncomplicated, recurrent shoulder dislocation is “Arthroscopic Bankart Repair”.
Perfect image thanks to HD Cameras…
During the procedure, a special camera (arthroscope) and arthroscopic surgical instruments are used, which are placed into the joint through two or three small incisions. The surgeon performs the surgery through the screen on which the images obtained through the arthroscope are transferred.
After arthroscopy, you can return to your daily life in a short time…
Thanks to the small size of the incisions and the surgical instruments used, there is very little pain after the surgery, and rehabilitation is easier than open surgery.
After the surgery, you will need to use a shoulder arm sling that secures your arm to your torso for 2 (two) weeks. During this period, your doctor will explain some exercises, such as pendulum exercises by opening your strap.
You can return to all your activities, including sports activities, in the 3rd month of the surgery…
In the 2nd (second) week of the surgery, your stitches will be removed. Starting from the second week, you will enter a period in which your physiotherapist will make you perform different exercise types, especially strengthening, and you will use the shoulder arm sling at night and only outside.
Starting from the 6th (sixth) week of the surgery, the shoulder arm sling will be completely removed and a physiotherapy process, including outward stretching, will begin.
You will be allowed to return to all your sports activities in the 3rd (third) month of the surgery. At the end of the treatment, you will be able to have a shoulder joint that is as mobile as possible and does not dislocate…
Explore our Shoulder Arthroscopy page for minimally invasive shoulder techniques and Rotator Cuff Tendon Repair for tendon injuries.
Week-by-Week Recovery and Return-to-Sports Timeline
- Day 1: Patients are discharged comfortably the day after surgery wearing a protective shoulder sling.
- Week 2: Stitches are removed at our Nisantasi, Istanbul practice and guided passive mobility exercises begin.
- Weeks 4 – 6: The sling is discontinued, transitioning to active range-of-motion and strengthening exercises.
- Month 3: Full return to sports and overhead activities without fear of re-dislocation.
Pre-Operative Preparation and Essential Post-Operative Care Guidelines
Achieving an outstanding orthopedic surgical outcome depends equally on precision surgical technique in the operating room and structured pre- and post-operative rehabilitation. At our private medical practice in Nisantasi, Sisli, Istanbul (Harbiye, Abdi Ipekci St. Ada Apt No:22), every patient’s journey is managed according to international quality protocols:
- Comprehensive Pre-Operative Medical Assessment: Complete laboratory workups and anesthesia evaluations are conducted prior to surgery to tailor the safest anesthetic plan and manage chronic medications such as blood thinners.
- Multimodal Pain Control Protocol: Targeted regional nerve blocks and personalized analgesia protocols ensure that patients experience a remarkably comfortable, pain-free early recovery phase.
- Early Mobilization and Joint Motion: Supervised range-of-motion exercises and ambulation begin within the first 24 hours after surgery to prevent joint stiffness, preserve muscle tone, and promote healthy circulation.
- Waterproof Sterile Wound Care: Advanced waterproof surgical dressings applied before hospital discharge allow patients to shower safely at home while keeping the incision protected.
- Direct Physician Follow-Up & Progressive Rehabilitation: During scheduled follow-up visits at our Nisantasi practice, wound healing, joint range of motion, and muscle recovery are directly evaluated by Prof. Dr. Nevzat Selim Gokay at every milestone.
Frequently Asked Questions
Why does a dislocated shoulder keep dislocating repeatedly?
During the initial dislocation, the stabilizing cartilage rim (labrum) and ligaments tear. Especially in young, active patients, untreated tears allow the joint to slip out repeatedly.
How do you choose between arthroscopic Bankart repair and open bone-block surgery?
Arthroscopic labral repair is the gold standard when bone stock is intact. If repeated dislocations have caused significant glenoid bone loss, a bone-block transfer procedure is selected.
When can I return to sports after shoulder instability surgery?
Following 4–6 weeks of sling protection and progressive physical therapy, patients resume daily activities at Week 6 and return to full sports by Month 3.
Do the suture anchors stay in the body, and are they MRI-safe?
Modern all-suture and biocomposite anchors are microscopic, biocompatible implants that remain safely embedded in bone. They cannot be felt, do not trigger metal detectors, and are 100% safe for future MRI scans.
What is the success rate in preventing future dislocations?
When the surgical technique (Bankart repair, Remplissage, or Latarjet) is properly matched to the patient’s bone and soft tissue profile, stability success rates exceed 95%.
Why shouldn’t surgery be delayed if the shoulder keeps dislocating?
Every dislocation chips away bone from the glenoid rim and damages articular cartilage, turning a simple soft-tissue tear into a complex bony defect.
Are Anadolu Sigorta, Allianz Sigorta, and Türkiye İş Bankası agreements valid for this treatment?
Yes. Direct agreements with Anadolu Sigorta, Allianz Sigorta, and Türkiye İş Bankası active employees, retirees, and eligible dependents are valid for medical examinations, diagnostic evaluations, and surgical treatment procedures at our Nisantasi, Istanbul practice.